Event and Time
Event Description
Corey Hadow was tried for multiple offenses, including intentionally causing injury. A jury found him guilty of intentionally causing injury but not guilty of four other charges. Hadow pleaded guilty to several summary charges related to dangerous articles and driving offenses, while disputing charges of careless driving and failing to wear a helmet.
Application and Claims
- The prosecution sought a sentence of combined imprisonment and a Community Correction Order for Hadow.
- Hadow’s defense counsel argued for a Community Correction Order, citing mitigating factors such as his personal circumstances and plea for some charges.
- In relation to the charge of intentionally causing injury, the jury assessed the evidence provided during the trial, particularly rejecting conflicting accounts regarding self-defense.
Judicial Decisions
- The jury accepted the testimony of witness Brett Eustace regarding Hadow’s actions towards victim Mr. Kreun, while rejecting the evidence provided by Kreun and his granddaughter.
- The court confirmed the jury's finding of guilt on the charge of intentionally causing injury, finding the injury was not "serious" as defined by law, leading to a lesser charge.
- Hadow was found guilty of failing to wear a helmet but not guilty of careless driving based on witness evidence.
Dispute Points and Legal Basis
Dispute Points
- Prosecution Claims: Argued for a severe penalty given the injuries sustained by Mr. Kreun and the circumstances of the attack.
- Defense Arguments:
- Requested leniency, citing Hadow's personal circumstances, his full-time employment, and his continuous bail compliance without re-offending. - They acknowledged his plea of guilty to certain charges as a factor deserving mitigation.
- Evidence Considered:
- The testimony of Brett Eustace, which described Hadow’s violent behavior towards Kreun. - Medical evidence regarding Kreun's injuries, supporting the severity of the assault. - Witness Jamie Maxwell provided evidence suggesting that Hadow's driving was not as reckless as claimed.