```markdown
Event and Time
Event Description
This case originated on 25 March 2020, initiated by George Hrycenko (the plaintiff) to obtain judicial declarations regarding two properties owned by the first defendant, VHY Enterprises Pty Ltd (VHY). The plaintiff aimed for the properties to be sold to satisfy a substantial judgment debt resulting from an earlier proceeding against his son, Victor Hrycenko, who is the sole director of VHY.
Application and Claims
- The plaintiff sought declarations of equitable interest in the properties located at:
- 486 Nepean Highway, Frankston (Frankston Property) - 6 Dromana Parade, Safety Beach (Safety Beach Property)
- The plaintiff also requested:
- An order under section 91 of the Property Law Act 1958 (Vic) to sell the properties, with proceeds distributed as follows: - First: Cover the sale costs. - Second: Discharge the first mortgage in favor of Dnister on both properties. - Third: Satisfy the judgment debt owed to the plaintiff from Victor. - Fourth: Deposit any remaining proceeds into Court.
Judicial Decisions
- The Court proposed to order a judicial sale of the properties, subject to further conditions and oversight regarding the sale terms and methods.
Dispute Points and Legal Basis
Dispute Points
- Plaintiff's Claims:
- Asserts equitable interests and seeks judicial sale of properties to satisfy judgment. - Claims properties were charged to secure his interests.
- Defendants' Arguments:
- VHY (1st Defendant): Challenges the existence and extent of the plaintiff's equitable interest. - Dnister (2nd Defendant): Holds a first mortgage security interest and seeks priority in payment from the property sale proceeds. - and (3rd & 4th Defendants): Contest the claims, having lodged caveats asserting interests as chargees over the properties.